menu
Tatoeba
language
Register Log in
language English
menu
Tatoeba

chevron_right Register

chevron_right Log in

Browse

chevron_right Show random sentence

chevron_right Browse by language

chevron_right Browse by list

chevron_right Browse by tag

chevron_right Browse audio

Community

chevron_right Wall

chevron_right List of all members

chevron_right Languages of members

chevron_right Native speakers

search
clear
swap_horiz
search

Sentence #308686

info_outline Metadata
warning
Your sentence was not added because the following already exists.
Sentence #{{vm.sentence.id}} — belongs to {{vm.sentence.user.username}} Sentence #{{vm.sentence.id}}
{{vm.sentence.furigana.info_message}} {{vm.sentence.text}}
star This sentence belongs to a native speaker.
warning This sentence is not reliable.
content_copy Copy sentence info Go to sentence page
subdirectory_arrow_right
warning
{{transcription.info_message}}
Translations
Unlink this translation link Make into direct translation chevron_right
{{translation.furigana.info_message}} {{translation.text}} Existing sentence #{{::translation.id}} has been added as a translation.
edit Edit this translation
warning This sentence is not reliable.
content_copy Copy sentence info Go to sentence page
subdirectory_arrow_right
warning
{{transcription.info_message}}
Translations of translations
Unlink this translation link Make into direct translation chevron_right
{{translation.furigana.info_message}} {{translation.text}} Existing sentence #{{::translation.id}} has been added as a translation.
edit Edit this translation
warning This sentence is not reliable.
content_copy Copy sentence info Go to sentence page
subdirectory_arrow_right
warning
{{transcription.info_message}}
{{vm.expandableIcon}} {{vm.sentence.expandLabel}} Fewer translations

Comments

blay_paul blay_paul May 16, 2010 May 16, 2010 at 11:58:24 AM UTC link Permalink

Bump

Admittedly the previous version was a comma splice - but I think it was clearer in meaning. Reading it now I tend to think "How many sisters does she have who don't live in Kyoto?"

How about a semi-colon or a dash?

She has two sisters; who live in Kyoto.
She has two sisters - who live in Kyoto.

Dorenda Dorenda June 5, 2010 June 5, 2010 at 1:08:22 PM UTC link Permalink

I know, a late reaction, but this semicolon caught my attention...

First, I don't think the original sentence was a comma splice, at least not if the Wikipedia definition of it is correct (I had never heard the term "comma splice" before): "Comma splicing is the use of a comma to join two independent clauses, instead of a conjunction, semi-colon, or period." The sentence didn't have two independent clauses, but an independent and a dependent (relative) clause. So actually I don't know why the comma had to be removed.

Second, removing the comma makes the relative clause restrictive, as blay_paul already noted when he said he tends to think "How many sisters does she have who don't live in Kyoto?", so it changes the meaning of the sentence.
(Wikipedia again: "A relative clause takes commas if it is non-restrictive, as in I cut down all the trees, which were over six feet tall. (Without the comma, this would imply that only some of the trees – those over six feet tall – were cut down.)")

Third, I don't think semicolons are used to seperate dependent clauses, only independent clauses, so the current version of the sentence is not correct, if you ask me.

If you really don't like the version with the comma, I suggest just removing it alltogether, since there are some other equivalent sentences already now.

:)

blay_paul blay_paul June 5, 2010 June 5, 2010 at 1:40:02 PM UTC link Permalink

OK, I'm putting the comma back - CK can argue with me when (if) he notices. :-)

Metadata

close

Lists

Sentence text

License: CC BY 2.0 FR

Logs

We cannot determine yet whether this sentence was initially derived from translation or not.

She has two sisters, who live in Kyoto.

added by an unknown member, date unknown

She has two sisters who live in Kyoto.

edited by CK, May 13, 2010

She has two sisters; who live in Kyoto.

edited by blay_paul, June 5, 2010

She has two sisters, who live in Kyoto.

edited by blay_paul, June 5, 2010