Your sentence was not added because the following already exists.
Well, for me, in Spanish "¿De dónde vienes?" is about the last place you were, and is different than ""¿De dónde eres?" which is about the city/country you live or were born. Is it the same kind of distinction you're trying to do with the English sentences ?
I'm not sure for the translation of the idiomatic meaning, we should ask a Spanish native-speaker.
Hi, I'm not a native Spanish speaker, but I think it seems to be better to unlink both senses.
Where are you from? -> ¿De dónde eres/sos o es Ud./son Uds.?
Where are you coming from? -> ¿De dónde vienes/venís o viene Ud./vienen Uds.?
But the opinion of a native surely were a little bit helpful.
Tags
View all tagsSentence text
License: CC BY 2.0 FRAudio
License:
{{vm.getLicenseName(audio.license)}}
{{vm.getLicenseName(audio.license)}}
Logs
We cannot determine yet whether this sentence was initially derived from translation or not.
De dónde vienes?
added by an unknown member, date unknown
➜ #461
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
➜ #1656
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
linked by Dorenda, June 4, 2010
¿De dónde vienes?
edited by Espi, August 21, 2010
linked by oriol_vallverdu, September 11, 2010
¿De dónde vienes?
added by aye1995, December 17, 2010
linked by aye1995, December 17, 2010
linked by papabear, January 8, 2011
linked by Shishir, September 14, 2011
linked by marcelostockle, April 2, 2012
¿De dónde vienes?
added by marcelostockle, April 2, 2012
linked by marcelostockle, April 15, 2012
linked by marcelostockle, October 23, 2012
¿De dónde vienes?
added by Shishir, November 18, 2012
linked by Shishir, December 1, 2012
linked by Shishir, December 1, 2012
¿De dónde vienes?
added by Shishir, March 28, 2013
linked by Shishir, March 28, 2013
linked by cueyayotl, April 13, 2014
linked by cueyayotl, January 3, 2015
linked by marcelostockle, January 17, 2015
linked by martinod, January 29, 2015
linked by cueyayotl, February 8, 2015
linked by cueyayotl, February 11, 2015
linked by marafon, February 24, 2016
linked by marafon, February 24, 2016
linked by cueyayotl, April 16, 2016
unlinked by deniko, January 24, 2017
linked by deniko, January 24, 2017
linked by JUNE_EUSKARA1, November 27, 2017
linked by driini, January 18, 2019
linked by Rockaround, January 30, 2019
linked by driini, January 26, 2020
linked by MarijnKp, October 27, 2020
linked by xjjAstrus, October 30, 2020
linked by puppetshow, February 28, 2024
