menu
Tatoeba
language
Register Log in
language English
menu
Tatoeba

chevron_right Register

chevron_right Log in

Browse

chevron_right Show random sentence

chevron_right Browse by language

chevron_right Browse by list

chevron_right Browse by tag

chevron_right Browse audio

Community

chevron_right Wall

chevron_right List of all members

chevron_right Languages of members

chevron_right Native speakers

search
clear
swap_horiz
search

Sentence #435074

info_outline Metadata
There is no sentence with id 435074

Comments

Vortarulo Vortarulo February 6, 2011 February 6, 2011 at 9:54:45 PM UTC link Permalink

Please decide for one version, don't include alternative translations!

Swift Swift April 15, 2011 April 15, 2011 at 4:59:48 PM UTC link Permalink

@NNC/TC: Possibly a corruption of the German “Guten Appetit”?

lukaszpp lukaszpp April 25, 2011 April 25, 2011 at 5:52:48 PM UTC link Permalink

I'm not native, I'm not sure if it is translated correct.

Shiawase Shiawase May 27, 2011 May 27, 2011 at 6:16:04 PM UTC link Permalink

--responding to @needs native check--
This isn't said in English.
There isn't really an English version of "Bon Appetite" or "Guten Appetit" etc. A waiter might say "enjoy your meal" (or the Americanism "enjoy" ) or a friend might say "dig in!" but I can't say that there is any appropriate translation of the Japanese いただきます, literally "I humbly receive", which is said by everyone at the table at about the same time and isn't something a waiter or customer would say. In a previous age a prayer before meals would have been common in Christian cultures.

lukaszpp lukaszpp May 29, 2011 May 29, 2011 at 10:25:28 AM UTC link Permalink

@Shiawase: Would you better delete it or wish me to change it into "non-literal" translation?

Shiawase Shiawase May 29, 2011 May 29, 2011 at 9:42:03 PM UTC link Permalink

@lukaszpp
My opinion is that it should be deleted as something that isn't said in English.
I'd prefer to lose something from the corpus than include something that could mislead learners.
*However* you need advice from someone more familiar with this project, CK or Swift perhaps.

zipangu zipangu May 29, 2011 May 29, 2011 at 10:06:33 PM UTC link Permalink

In my opinion it should not be deleted. Anyway, Tatoeba lacks any kind of commentary or context information, which actually is essential to properly translate given sentence, acquire a foreign language. Some sentences in the corpus do sound unnatural if spoken in a number of real life situations by a native speaker, but they are accurate translations.

This concerns especially behabitives (i.e. 'good morning' etc.) and second-person ways of address. Their pragmatic distribution is so sifferent in various languages and so much context-dependent that without providing appropriate information on the context the translation simply cannot be done.

Back to the point: learning a foreign language from separate sentences in Tatoeba (or elsewhere) is rather silly idea for a student, so I guess the risk of misleading learners seems to be rather low.

The English phrase in question IS a proper translation in terms of raw language, but it doesn't mean it can fill a gap in terms of pragmatics and everyday language habits.

Shiawase Shiawase May 30, 2011 May 30, 2011 at 1:38:35 AM UTC link Permalink

>so I guess the risk of misleading learners seems to be rather low.

My understanding of one of the aims of this project IS to provide quality learning resources (but not to directly be a learning site) and another is to provide natural expressions.

Certainly the corpus is being used in many Japanese - English - Japanese dictionaries used by beginning language learners. There is frustration about the examples and a significant proportion of that data could be improved. So I'd say potential does exist for learners to be misled, especially as there are so many self-led learners these days.

Nor is "good appetite" a literal or raw translation of "いただきます". If anything at it's most basic it just means "receive" It probably should be unlinked from that in my view. I can't comment on the translations that have been derived from it.

I would suggest instead that an expanded example is made to better illustrate the use and context of いただきます. I'll have a go when I'm feeling more awake...



JimBreen JimBreen May 30, 2011 May 30, 2011 at 2:17:21 AM UTC link Permalink

The simple solution is to delink いただきます. None of the others (that I can understand) are correct translations of it. (I see we don't have ご馳走様でした。 as a "sentence" either - perhaps I'll add it.)

Swift Swift June 11, 2011 June 11, 2011 at 12:44:16 PM UTC link Permalink

I've unlinked the Japanese sentences.

lukaszpp lukaszpp June 16, 2011 June 16, 2011 at 5:02:44 PM UTC link Permalink

If you consider it as nonsense, please delete it.

Swift Swift June 22, 2011 June 22, 2011 at 12:32:04 PM UTC link Permalink

Deleting unnatural sentence.

Metadata

close

Logs

Hearty/Good appetite!

added by TRANG, July 22, 2010

linked by TRANG, July 22, 2010

linked by Geek_God, October 14, 2010

Good appetite!

added by Guybrush88, January 27, 2011

linked by Guybrush88, January 27, 2011

linked by Guybrush88, January 27, 2011

linked by Guybrush88, January 27, 2011

linked by brauliobezerra, January 27, 2011

Good appetite!

edited by lukaszpp, February 11, 2011

linked by lukaszpp, February 11, 2011

linked by LugoIlmer, April 9, 2011

linked by LugoIlmer, April 9, 2011

linked by Coyolxauhqui, April 25, 2011

linked by Scott, June 1, 2011

linked by Scott, June 1, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 11, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 11, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 11, 2011

Good appetite!

deleted by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011

unlinked by Swift, June 22, 2011