menu
Tatoeba
language
Registriĝi Ensaluti
language Esperanto
menu
Tatoeba

chevron_right Registriĝi

chevron_right Ensaluti

Foliumi

chevron_right Montri hazardan frazon

chevron_right Foliumi laŭ lingvo

chevron_right Foliumi laŭ listo

chevron_right Foliumi laŭ etikedo

chevron_right Foliumi sonregistraĵojn

Komunumo

chevron_right Muro

chevron_right Listo de ĉiuj membroj

chevron_right Lingvoj de la membroj

chevron_right Denaskaj parolantoj

search
clear
swap_horiz
search
DostKaplan DostKaplan 2019-aprilo-18, modifita 2019-aprilo-18 2019-aprilo-18 10:12:26 UTC, modifita 2019-aprilo-18 10:17:17 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

English --> French

https://tatoeba.org/eng/sentenc...rom=eng&to=fra

I see French and Turkish results.

But when I choose, English --> Any Language

https://tatoeba.org/eng/sentenc...rom=eng&to=und

The French result is missing. In fact, there should at least be a result in German, too.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[31695] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} kaŝi la respondojn montri la respondojn
AlanF_US AlanF_US 2019-aprilo-18 2019-aprilo-18 14:37:42 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

You have the following items in your "Languages" list in your settings:

tur, ara, eng, zsm

When you do a search with French as your "To" language, you are shown results with French as well. But when you do a search with "Any language" as your "To" language, you will only see results in the languages in your list. If you want to see results in other languages as well, you should add them to your "Languages" list, or you should clear out that list. But if you do not clear out the list, you should remember that it will affect your results.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[31696] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} kaŝi la respondojn montri la respondojn
DostKaplan DostKaplan 2019-aprilo-22 2019-aprilo-22 10:05:15 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

I find the behavior with respect to the "To" language and the languages in my "Languages" list somewhat inconsistent and confusing. The behavior is not apparent to the user. Perhaps have a checkbox below the "To" language:

[ ] Include languages in my Languages list

Otherwise, if the languages in my "Languages" are to be used for the results, then at least be consistent about it. If I search for a very common word like "love", I see results using the "To" language as well as the languages in my "Languages" list, as you said. But if I search for a less common word like "profound", and my "To" language is "Malay" (zsm) which _also_ happens to be one of the languages in my "Languages" list (tur, ara, eng, zsm), I get zero results even though there are translations for Turkish. If the standard behavior is that languages in my "Languages" are to be used for the results, then I would expect to see results if any one of the languages in my "Languages" list has results regardless of whether the "To" language has results (but _especially_ if my "To" language happens to be one of the languages in my "Languages" list). As it is, that's not what's happening.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[31722] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} kaŝi la respondojn montri la respondojn
AlanF_US AlanF_US 2019-aprilo-23 2019-aprilo-23 17:26:33 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

I see your point. However, even though there is an apparent inconsistency from one standpoint, the behavior is consistent from another.

The purpose of the "To" language is to limit hits to sentences that have translations in that language. By contrast, the purpose of the language list in your settings is to control the display of those sentences. Thus, if you search for sentences with "love" with Malay as your "To" language, you will get sentences that have (direct or indirect) translations of "love" (as well as "lovely", "loves", etc.) into Malay. As a bonus, you will see translations into Turkish and Arabic, BUT ONLY FOR THOSE SENTENCES THAT HAVE TRANSLATIONS INTO MALAY. By contrast, if you search for sentences with "profound" with Malay as your "To" language, and there are no matches in Malay, you won't get any hits. The fact that there are matches in Turkish doesn't matter.