menu
Tatoeba
language
Registriĝi Ensaluti
language Esperanto
menu
Tatoeba

chevron_right Registriĝi

chevron_right Ensaluti

Foliumi

chevron_right Montri hazardan frazon

chevron_right Foliumi laŭ lingvo

chevron_right Foliumi laŭ listo

chevron_right Foliumi laŭ etikedo

chevron_right Foliumi sonregistraĵojn

Komunumo

chevron_right Muro

chevron_right Listo de ĉiuj membroj

chevron_right Lingvoj de la membroj

chevron_right Denaskaj parolantoj

search
clear
swap_horiz
search
fajro fajro 2009-decembro-08 2009-decembro-08 03:07:39 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

Tatoeba should use a license without "by" like CC0:
http://creativecommons.org/about/cc0

Attribution is unnecessary and unpractical.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[35] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} kaŝi la respondojn montri la respondojn
sysko sysko 2009-decembro-08 2009-decembro-08 10:06:52 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

in fact it's only legal problem european law say one can't abandon his moral against a text, except 50 years after his death, 70 years in France, so CC0 can't be choosen
anyway we're looking if there's any problem to go to a less restrictive licence such as CC-BY, we will be sure at the end of the week

{{vm.hiddenReplies[36] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} kaŝi la respondojn montri la respondojn
fajro fajro 2009-decembro-08 2009-decembro-08 12:32:55 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

I like cc-sa (is almost Public Domain!) http://creativecommons.org/licenses/sa/1.0/ sadly "retired"

{{vm.hiddenReplies[37] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} kaŝi la respondojn montri la respondojn
sysko sysko 2009-decembro-08 2009-decembro-08 12:43:37 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

unfortunately as explain in my last message, due to european/french author right, attribution is mandatory and CC0 is still not clear whether it works in france or not, so we prefer to be safe, regardin that make law pursuit for copyright violiation is "fashion" in france ...

so the most "free" we can do is "CC-BY" ( for the moment my research hasn't show anything against it, but I prefer to check juridiction of main countries), when CC0 will be clearer regarding countries which has the notion of moral right (basically all european countries) , for further information, you can read the CC discussions pages, there, you can find more precise technical explanation :)

sysko sysko 2009-decembro-08 2009-decembro-08 10:15:28 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

*his moral right
that means globally that we must attribute works of contributors, as we're based in europe and a major part of contributions (except takana corpus original sentences) after some internal discussion we've realized that maybe CC-BY can be used, as Tatoeba MUST attribute works, after if people want to reuse the contributions without attributing it to original contributors, that will be their problem (in fact no problem as long as they don't reuse without attributing sentences or corrections from european contributors or other countries where public domain is different from US definition)
so the licence is only to make things clear

by the way, we wouldn't have take a long time to choose a licence or so if there were no threats nor possible juridical problem, I far prefer coding than looking into law books

sysko sysko 2009-decembro-12 2009-decembro-12 13:17:53 UTC link Konstanta ligilo

the content will now be licenced under CC-BY 2.0 FR, which is for the moment, the less restrictive we can do according to european law