menu
Tatoeba
language
登録する ログイン
language 日本語
menu
Tatoeba

chevron_right 登録する

chevron_right ログイン

閲覧する

chevron_right ランダム表示

chevron_right 言語を指定して見る

chevron_right リストごとに見る

chevron_right タグごとに見る

chevron_right 音声つきの例文を見る

コミュニティ

chevron_right 掲示板

chevron_right メンバー一覧

chevron_right 言語ごとのメンバー

chevron_right Native speakers

search
clear
swap_horiz
search

メニュー

掲示板に戻る

blay_paul blay_paul 2010年5月7日 2010年5月7日 8:20:20 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

Suggestion box

Just thought of a quick idea for comments / wall postings.

Some sort of BBcode or tag system to mark sentence numbers in coment text so they can be turned automatically into links.

e.g. "See also ##250165"
would turn into
"See also <a href=tatoeba.org/eng/sentences/show/250165>250165</a>"

{{vm.hiddenReplies[720] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} 返信を非表示 返信を表示
Swift Swift 2010年5月7日 2010年5月7日 10:34:38 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

I was just about to suggest the same thing. This would be immensely useful.

TRANG TRANG 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 16:26:24 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

Yes, it's something I've been thinking about as well... But the question is, what format to use?

As far as I'm concerned, I'd tend to write it with only one #.
"See also #250165"

But perhaps it's too simple and there can be issues with this, I don't know.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[722] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} 返信を非表示 返信を表示
sysko sysko 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 16:30:23 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

I think ## is better

{{vm.hiddenReplies[723] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} 返信を非表示 返信を表示
blay_paul blay_paul 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 18:31:29 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

I also recommend ## rather than #, because you will be less likely to get false positives.

Swift Swift 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 16:42:42 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

How about using the "nº"? It will hardly be used for anything else and is available on every page by the sentence number, ready to be copied along with it.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[724] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} 返信を非表示 返信を表示
blay_paul blay_paul 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 18:32:42 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

Except that there is no "nº" displayed on 'the Wall' so it would only really work for comments there, not posts here as well.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[726] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} 返信を非表示 返信を表示
Swift Swift 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 20:06:34 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

Why would there need to be one displayed on the Wall? It's where you look up the sentence number.
... well, unless you have it memorised.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[729] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} 返信を非表示 返信を表示
blay_paul blay_paul 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 20:38:59 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

Sentence numbers are also included in the csv export files. (Which I often work from)

OK, I'll admit it - I just don't like nº's.

Swift Swift 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 20:17:00 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

Actually, perhaps it's just easiest to go with something dead-easy. The #<number> is nicer than the ##<number> unless the latter markup were trimmed somehow, but that would make the usage unclear to new users.

The occasional false-positive wouldn't be obtrusive and well balanced out by getting people to drop the use of the hash character in their writing.

Oh, and if we're building a bike-shed, I want it red and will fight anyone who thinks otherwise tooth and nail!

contour contour 2010年5月8日 2010年5月8日 21:02:17 UTC flag Report link 固定リンク

A format I've seen other places is sentence #123, which is convenient because you can generalize it to list #123, wall #123, etc. Sentence links may be common enough to warrant a shorter special syntax, though.

I also think the syntax should be kept in the final post, e.g. if you use ##, it should turn into <a href=tatoeba.org/eng/sentences/show/123>##123</a>, so new users can immediately tell how it's done. Using the format other places, like in the message logs, also helps discoverability.