要畀一個母語係廣東話嘅人檢查一下。
1) Since the English says 'asking' rather than 'ask', it's better to put a 緊 after 問 to emphasise the continuity of the action.
2) 意思 is usually taken to mean meaning of tangible things, like definitions of words. For things like 生命, a better word would be 意義.
3) The current sentence structure is a bit cumbersome - 你仲問緊自己生命嘅意義呀 (without the 係咩嘢) means just the same thing. If you don't mind the translation being too liberal, you can further simplify the sentence into something like this: 你仲喺度諗緊生命嘅意義呀?
By the way, you may know this already, but the 呀 at the end should be pronounced as aa4 instead of aa3 :-)
> By the way, you may know this already, but the 呀 at the
> end should be pronounced as aa4 instead of aa3 :-)
No, I never knew this. :)
http://www.cantonese.sheik.co.u..._particles.htm says that aa3 is "used in neutral questions", while aa4 is used "in questions expecting agreement"...
Though I've never knew when to use which one. ^^"
I'm not sure if that's a very good way of distinguishing the two. It's actually a lot simpler. When you remove an aa3 from a question, it would still be a question; but when you remove an aa4 from a question, it would be transformed into a statement.
For example,
你今朝有冇食早餐呀 (aa3)?
(Did you have breakfast this morning?)
Remove the aa3 → 你今朝有冇食早餐?
It still means 'Did you have breakfast this morning?'
你今朝冇食早餐呀 (aa4)?
(You didn't have breakfast this morning?)
Remove the aa4 → 你今朝冇食早餐。
The meaning becomes 'You didn't have breakfast this morning.'
The same thing applies to '你仲喺度諗緊生命嘅意義呀?'. If you remove the final 呀, the sentence would be transformed into a statement:
你仲喺度諗緊生命嘅意義。
(You are still thinking about the meaning of life.)
Therefore, you can be sure that the 呀 is pronounced as aa4. As simple as that ;-) !
Wow, thanks for the explanation!
Label
Tampilkan semua labelSentence text
License: CC BY 2.0 FRLog
Kalimat ini awalnya ditambahkan sebagai terjemahan dari kalimat#2210
ditambahkan oleh Demetrius, 6 Maret 2012
ditautkan oleh Demetrius, 6 Maret 2012
diedit oleh Demetrius, 10 Maret 2012
ditautkan oleh LeeSooHa, 12 Juni 2022
ditautkan oleh LeeSooHa, 12 Juni 2022