menu
Tatoeba
language
Cofrestru Mewngofnodi
language Cymraeg
menu
Tatoeba

chevron_right Cofrestru

chevron_right Mewngofnodi

Pori

chevron_right Show random sentence

chevron_right Pori yn ôl iaith

chevron_right Pori yn ôl rhestr

chevron_right Pori yn ôl tag

chevron_right Pori sain

Community

chevron_right Mur

chevron_right Rhestr o bob aelod

chevron_right Languages of members

chevron_right Native speakers

search
clear
swap_horiz
search

Dewislen

Yn ôl i'r mur

deniko deniko 18 Awst 2020 18 Awst 2020 am 09:42:52 UTC flag Report link Permalink

Has the possibility of getting rid of language flags ever been considered, and if yes, what was the final decision (if there was one)? I believe the ISO codes will do a better job.

Obviously, inspired by the Impersonator's post about the Belarusian flag, just didn't want to rain on his parade mentioning another possibility there, as these are two separate topics.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[35800] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} cuddio'r ymatebion dangos yr ymatebion
User55521 User55521 18 Awst 2020 18 Awst 2020 am 10:01:03 UTC flag Report link Permalink

This idea is brought up from time to time, and it's usually dismissed. Here're what Trang says:

> «Removing flags doesn't solve everything.
> It only replaces one problem with another.
> Without flags, you'll have, for sure, people
> telling you they have a harder time spotting
> sentences in their desired language and
> protesting to get the flags back. Flags are
> one of the core elements of Tatoeba's UI.
> You cannot just remove them and expect that nobody will care.
>
> It is a design choice and yes, it costs us, once
> in a while, very intense and even violent
> discussions. But it's a price we have agreed
> to pay in exchange of the possibility to give our
> languages a visual identity. You don't have
> to agree with this choice»

Source: https://tatoeba.org/ukr/wall/sh...#message_29992

> I believe the ISO codes will do a better job.

I personally don't like ISO codes because they're in Latin script, which is not really neutral.

{{vm.hiddenReplies[35802] ? 'expand_more' : 'expand_less'}} cuddio'r ymatebion dangos yr ymatebion
deniko deniko 18 Awst 2020 18 Awst 2020 am 10:05:51 UTC flag Report link Permalink

Thanks. So, basically, proposed and dismissed.