
This seems to be potentially ambiguous:
tell me [something] when you get back OR tell me the time you (will) get back

And I quote someone else,
"Please tell me when you get back. = He will get back before he tells you OR He will tell you his planned return time.
Please tell me when you'll get back. = He will tell you his planned return time.
etc."
Why is this then not ambiguous?

>Why is this then not ambiguous?
The above sentence isn't ambiguous. It means "When I come back, I'll tell you something." It doesn't and cannot mean that the person is indicating the time that he/she will return. That would be "I'll tell you when I'll be back." or similar.
> "Please tell me when you get back. = He will get back before he tells you
- correct, I'm asking him to tell me something after he gets back.
>OR He will tell you his planned return time.
- no, "Please tell me when you get back" can't mean that. - see sentence below for that meaning.
Please tell me when you'll get back. = He will tell you his planned return time. - correct

Well, I guess that was a minority opinion... there are too many varieties to get a hang of everything :$
Tags
View all tagsLists
Sentence text
License: CC BY 2.0 FRAudio
Logs
This sentence is original and was not derived from translation.
added by CK, July 1, 2013
linked by alpha44, August 16, 2013
linked by duran, August 20, 2013
linked by Guybrush88, September 16, 2013
linked by Guybrush88, September 16, 2013
linked by Guybrush88, September 16, 2013
linked by Henu, September 19, 2013
linked by Henu, September 19, 2013
linked by korobo4ka, October 11, 2013
linked by Diablofire, October 11, 2013
linked by gleki, October 11, 2013
linked by nueby, February 13, 2014
linked by PaulP, May 24, 2014
linked by maydoo, December 9, 2014
linked by Ooneykcall, December 9, 2014
linked by PaulP, December 9, 2014
linked by loghaD, December 10, 2014
linked by loghaD, December 10, 2014
linked by Pfirsichbaeumchen, December 16, 2014
unlinked by Pfirsichbaeumchen, December 16, 2014
linked by Zaghawa, January 7, 2015
linked by cykel, August 1, 2019
unlinked by driini, June 18, 2020
linked by driini, June 18, 2020
linked by kiseva33, December 31, 2022
linked by Dominika7, September 7, 2024
linked by Dominika7, September 7, 2024
linked by Proxima5, March 15, 2025
linked by Proxima5, March 15, 2025