
It is. Formally you are right, if we are to consider it according to a perfect language syntax. But it's a normal, everyday sentence. If it's worded as a question, it can usually be construed as referred to "you".

(I'm in favor of the version you suggested, but I believe that my version can also be found in everyday language).

**correcting my previous comment:
...as referred to "you" => ... as referring to "you".

Thanks for your comments. Changed.
Tags
View all tagsLists
Sentence text
License: CC BY 2.0 FRAudio
Logs
This sentence is original and was not derived from translation.
added by Eldad, September 16, 2011
linked by Eldad, September 16, 2011
linked by Eldad, September 16, 2011
linked by Eldad, September 16, 2011
linked by Eldad, September 16, 2011
linked by sacredceltic, September 17, 2011
linked by sacredceltic, September 17, 2011
linked by marcelostockle, January 17, 2012
linked by Amastan, August 29, 2012
linked by odexed, February 12, 2014
linked by PaulP, April 9, 2014
linked by Ooneykcall, April 10, 2014
linked by shanghainese, April 10, 2014
linked by marafon, April 10, 2014
linked by marafon, April 10, 2014
linked by marafon, April 10, 2014
edited by Eldad, April 12, 2014
edited by Eldad, April 12, 2014
linked by Joseph, April 13, 2014
linked by Silja, May 25, 2014
linked by fanty, September 7, 2014
linked by deyta, January 17, 2016
linked by marafon, March 21, 2020
linked by marafon, March 21, 2020
linked by marafon, March 21, 2020
linked by marafon, March 21, 2020
linked by bunbuku, February 4, 2021
linked by mayabe, April 22, 2024
linked by mayabe, April 22, 2024
linked by mayabe, April 22, 2024