I believe one generally uses the preposition "on" to refer a journey by train. A car takes "in", however.
"in the train" and "on the train" are both okay.
> I personally prefer "on the train."
I also say "on an airplane" even though we actually ride inside airplanes.
"on" does seem more common, but I would still argue that both are fine. It depends on the image you want to create.
I agree that both are fine and that there's a difference in the image evoked. But I also think that in English, the "on the train" image is evoked more often and more conventionally than the "in the train" one.
When I see the German "im Zug" or the French "dans le train", the first image that springs to my mind is that I'm "on the train" (= travelling by a moving train) rather than "in the train" (= sitting inside a train that may or may not be moving).
I changed it ^^
Sorry Swift, I hadn't see your comment, I don't know why...
Google raw results challenges again ? Yawn...
No sc, it's Google Fight now. This is 200% more awesome!
It's been around for years already. But it is ever so irrelevant when it comes to languages...
Please debates Google search results elsewhere so as to leave this space for discussing that particular sentence. The wall is an option.
Feel free, however, to leave a link to relevant discussions.
we're precisely discussing this very sentence, Swift, and you do not rule how we do it.
If you want to discuss these rules, please use the wall as well and feel free to leave a link.
The fact is that Google raw results' challenges are no evidence AT ALL of greater relevance of a verbal form over another contrary to what this particular discussion suggests.
By the way, I can't see how non natives can discuss whether "on the train" is better than "in the train" when I suspect even many natives themselves don't have a clue. Are you a native yourself, Swift? Of how many languages are you a native, exactly?
Tags
View all tagsLists
- English sentences checked by sundown
- English sentences with translations by 10 or more native-speaker translators - Based on the 2022-07-16 exported data - Over 30,000 sentences
- Translated by Tatoebans ✨
- English Sentences with Audio Linked to Spanish Sentences with Audio (Updated: 2021-01-31)
- NGSL - Level 1 (according to er-central.com/ogte) - List started on Dec. 2017
Sentence text
License: CC BY 2.0 FRAudio
Logs
We cannot determine yet whether this sentence was initially derived from translation or not.
added by an unknown member, date unknown
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
linked by an unknown member, date unknown
edited by Pharamp, May 26, 2010
linked by Pharamp, May 26, 2010
linked by contour, May 26, 2010
linked by brauliobezerra, July 4, 2010
linked by kitanokuma, July 23, 2010
linked by Swift, August 30, 2010
edited by Pharamp, September 6, 2010
linked by sysko, December 9, 2010
linked by boracasli, March 11, 2011
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by al_ex_an_der, January 30, 2012
linked by mookeee, June 15, 2012
linked by MrShoval, November 12, 2012
linked by Balamax, May 3, 2013
linked by Pharamp, January 29, 2014
unlinked by Pharamp, January 29, 2014
linked by ficion, October 19, 2014
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Silja, January 25, 2015
linked by AlanF_US, April 14, 2015
linked by marafon, August 21, 2015
linked by fathe, March 18, 2016
linked by PaulP, March 18, 2016
linked by tanay, November 13, 2016
linked by deniko, February 12, 2018
linked by deniko, February 12, 2018
linked by deniko, February 12, 2018
linked by deniko, February 12, 2018
linked by pastelite, April 19, 2020
linked by morbrorper, July 16, 2020
unlinked by lbdx, September 12, 2020
linked by DaoSeng, November 16, 2021
linked by Yorwba, November 16, 2021
linked by NikiTricky, November 13, 2023
linked by jms, May 1, 2024
linked by rul, May 25, 2024
linked by thanhcona40, July 9, 2024