![Espi](/img/profiles_36/20f8d81e86e907e63656e49e42acf07d.png?1536268829)
Kial ankoraŭfoje?
Tiu frazo jam ekzistis!
Bonvolu informi vin antaŭe!
![fs](/img/profiles_36/073a4956618e6f3040fa081025d6d18d.png?1536268829)
(eo) [Responde al Espi :]
Kial ? Certe nek intence, nek konscie mi tiel faris, se tiel mi efektive faris.
Sub kiu numero do reaperas la sama frazo ? Mi jhus serchis tion per la serchilo en la paghosupra verda strio, sed nur unu aperon de chi tiu frazo mi ricevis.
Mi estas tre nova uzanto de Tatoeba". Eble ion mi ne bone komprenis pri la funkciado.
![Espi](/img/profiles_36/20f8d81e86e907e63656e49e42acf07d.png?1536268829)
Estas la frazo #338325.
Amike
![fs](/img/profiles_36/073a4956618e6f3040fa081025d6d18d.png?1536268829)
Dankon !
La frazon 531750-an mi provas forvishi, sed vane.
![Horus](/img/profiles_36/horus.jpg?1536268829)
Duplicates of this sentence have been deleted:
x #2674513
x #2636052
x #2923446
x #3598392
x #3042557
x #3047263
![PaulP](/img/profiles_36/59640.png?1658122310)
Tiu formo, sen subjekto, estas laŭ mi tre stranga. Mi dirus: "Mi ne komprenas."
P.S. Mi nun vidas, ke vi ligis ĝin al "No comprendo", "No comprendes", "No comprende"... Ne, tio ne eblas en Esperanto. En la hispana la verbo klarigas, kiu estas la subjekto. En Esperanto vi nepre devas esprimi la subjekton.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![cueyayotl](/img/profiles_36/0cdb4680299f421b58906f0a1aed8485.png?1536268829)
Mi kredas ke la subjekto povas esti forigita, kiam ĝi estas sciate, ĉu ne? La samo okazas kmere: អត់(ne) យល់(kompreni) ។
Povus iĝi "Mi/Li/Ŝi/Ili ne komprenas", ĉiuj eblas :)
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![cueyayotl](/img/profiles_36/0cdb4680299f421b58906f0a1aed8485.png?1536268829)
http://bertilow.com/pmeg/gramat...zoj.html#i-tps
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![PaulP](/img/profiles_36/59640.png?1658122310)
La ligilo al PMEG konfirmas mian eldiron, ĉu ne? Oni ne forlasas la subjekton, krom en la u-modo.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![cueyayotl](/img/profiles_36/0cdb4680299f421b58906f0a1aed8485.png?1536268829)
Mi aludis al la parto sub:
"Alispecaj forlasoj de subjekto okazas nur en rapida ĉiutageca parolo, nur en ĉeffrazoj, kaj nur kiam la kunteksto plene klarigas, kiu estas la subjekto:
•– Kion li faris? – Iris al la urbo! = Li iris al la urbo!"
Tiu frazo estas respondo al iu situacio, kaj ne estis izolita frazo :)
Jes. Mi kredas, ke eŭropanoj ne esprimas sin tiel, ĉar tio ne estas bona okcidenteŭropolingva gramatiko. Tamen, tiu esperanta frazo ne ŝajnas min esti erara.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![PaulP](/img/profiles_36/59640.png?1658122310)
Mi samopinias, ke en iu difinita kunteksto tiu frazo povas esti ĝusta. Sed tie ĉi vi montras ĝin sen kunteksto. Lernantoj de la lingvo - kaj por tiuj Tatoeba estas kreata, ĉu ne? - kredos, ke "No entiendo, no entiende, no entienden" ktp en Esperanto estas "Ne komprenas" kaj tio ne estas vera.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![nimfeo](/img/profiles_36/a5aab849cd20c6f1de65669436f4e148.png?1536268829)
+1
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![odexed](/img/profiles_36/2b27c224f68609cc7dbe520ae01787c8.png?1536268829)
@al_ex_an_der
Once you've changed this sentence, you should unlink it from #4587047 - No entiende and #4587048 - No entienden. Be more careful, please.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# This comment was copied from #4587046 when duplicate sentences were merged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
![Horus](/img/profiles_36/horus.jpg?1536268829)
Duplicates of this sentence have been deleted:
x #4587046
Tags
View all tagsSentence text
License: CC BY 2.0 FRLogs
This sentence was initially added as a translation of sentence #3528
linked by Sprachprofi, November 29, 2009
added by Sprachprofi, November 29, 2009
linked by zipangu, January 12, 2010
linked by Pharamp, April 7, 2010
linked by Pharamp, April 7, 2010
linked by Dorenda, April 13, 2010
linked by Dorenda, May 2, 2010
linked by boracasli, August 22, 2010
added by Maksimo, October 8, 2010
linked by eliza, October 19, 2010
linked by CK, November 3, 2010
linked by danepo, November 7, 2010
added by Aleksej, November 12, 2010
linked by Aleksej, November 12, 2010
linked by Muelisto, November 12, 2010
linked by Shishir, November 13, 2010
linked by Shishir, November 13, 2010
linked by Nero, March 25, 2011
linked by Nero, March 25, 2011
linked by Nero, March 25, 2011
linked by ednorog, March 31, 2011
linked by shanghainese, April 3, 2011
linked by shanghainese, April 3, 2011
linked by Zifre, July 3, 2011
linked by Zifre, July 3, 2011
linked by Zifre, July 3, 2011
linked by Zifre, July 3, 2011
linked by Shishir, July 8, 2011
linked by Demetrius, December 29, 2011
added by glavkos, March 23, 2012
linked by glavkos, March 23, 2012
added by xicotenga, July 12, 2012
linked by xicotenga, July 12, 2012
added by soweli_Elepanto, July 28, 2012
linked by soweli_Elepanto, July 28, 2012
linked by sadhen, July 30, 2012
linked by sadhen, August 5, 2012
added by Alois, October 26, 2012
linked by Alois, October 26, 2012
added by Matheus, October 29, 2012
linked by Matheus, October 29, 2012
linked by Alois, April 9, 2013
added by Alois, April 9, 2013
linked by PaulP, July 11, 2014
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by Horus, January 20, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by martinod, July 23, 2015
linked by nimfeo, August 24, 2015
linked by cueyayotl, October 8, 2015
linked by martinod, October 12, 2015
linked by martinod, October 12, 2015
linked by martinod, October 12, 2015
linked by martinod, October 12, 2015
linked by martinod, October 12, 2015
linked by Horus, November 1, 2015
linked by Horus, November 1, 2015
linked by Horus, November 1, 2015
unlinked by cueyayotl, November 2, 2015
unlinked by cueyayotl, November 2, 2015
linked by danepo, March 6, 2016
linked by thechuff, September 26, 2017
linked by astru, October 7, 2017
linked by astru, October 18, 2017
linked by astru, October 18, 2017
linked by deniko, February 22, 2018
linked by astru, August 3, 2018
linked by shekitten, October 2, 2019
linked by shekitten, January 21, 2020
linked by Raizin, March 3, 2021
linked by shekitten, March 7, 2021
linked by glavsaltulo, August 5, 2021
linked by tjmdejesus, December 5, 2022
linked by rul, March 28, 2024